Posted on August 27, 2010, in Apologetics, CATHOLIC PAMPHLETS, Hell. Bookmark the permalink. 8 Comments.
- Join 316 other subscribers
- Reproduction or transcription of this blog's archival material is strictly forbidden without the express permission of the blogmaster. Permission for non-commercial reproduction will ordinarily be granted but please contact me before doing so.
-
Recent Posts
Top Posts
Categories
- Abortion
- Alcoholism
- Ancient Rome
- Anglicanism
- Annulments
- Apologetics
- Archbishop Aloysius Stepinac
- Archbishop David Kearney
- Archbishop John Charles McQuaid
- Archbishop John Mary Harty
- Archbishop Joseph Walsh
- Archbishop Maurice Fitzgibbon
- Archbishop Thomas Morris
- Archbishop William Walsh
- Architecture
- Argentina
- Baptism
- Bible
- Birth Control
- Bishop Con Lucey
- Bishop Daniel Cohalan (jnr)
- Bishop Denis Moynihan
- Bishop Michael Browne
- Bishop Thomas Nulty
- Bishop William Philbin
- Bishops' Pastorals
- Blessed Virgin Mary
- Buddhism
- Canon Sheehan
- Cardinal John D'Alton
- Cardinal Joseph MacRory
- Cardinal Michael Logue
- Cardinal Newman
- Cardinal Patrick O'Donnell
- Cardinal Paul Cullen
- Cardinal Richard Cushing
- Cardinal William Conway
- Catholic Action
- Catholic Bulletin
- Catholic Education
- CATHOLIC PAMPHLETS
- Catholic Social Teaching
- Catholic University of Ireland
- Celibacy
- Clonard Missions
- Communism
- Confession
- Confirmation
- Conscription Crisis
- Conversion
- Croagh Patrick
- Dancing
- Dating
- Decorum
- Devotions (miscellaneous)
- Dictionary
- Divorce
- Doctrine and Life
- Dominicans
- Dublin Institute of Catholic Sociology
- Eastern Christianity
- Economics
- Ecumenism
- Emigration
- English Literature
- Eucharist
- Existence of God
- Fatima
- Fr. Denis Fahey
- Fr. Edward Coyne
- Fr. Frederick Faber
- Fr. John Sullivan
- France
- Frank Duff
- Freemasonry
- Hell
- Holy Land
- Holy Name
- Holy Week
- Humour
- Images
- Indulgences
- Interest
- International Ethics
- International Eucharistic Congress, 1932
- Irish Catholic Historical Committee
- Irish Church-State Relations
- Irish Colleges on the Continent
- Irish Constitution
- Irish Ecclesiastical Record
- Irish History
- Irish Language
- Irish Liturgical Congress
- Irish Messenger
- Irish Monthly
- Irish Rebellion of 1641
- Islam
- Jansenism
- John XXIII
- Judaism
- Justification
- Legion of Mary
- Liturgy
- Lough Derg
- Lourdes
- Luke Wadding
- Magdalene Laundries
- Marriage
- Mass
- Matt Talbot
- Maynooth Catechism
- Maynooth Laymen's Annual
- Maynooth Seminary
- Maynooth Union Summer School
- Media Archives
- Mexico
- Missionaries
- Mixed Marriages
- Modernism
- Monasticism
- Mother and Child Scheme
- Motherhood
- Muintir na Tíre
- Music
- Natural Law
- New Zealand
- Novena
- Old Testament Series
- Original Sin
- Overpopulation
- Papacy
- Patrician Year (1961)
- Patrick Pearse
- Persecution
- Pius XII
- Poetry
- Portugal
- Processions
- Purgatory
- Purity
- Redemption
- Reformation
- Repentance
- Roger Casement
- Roman Canon
- Rosary
- Ryan and Murphy Reports
- Sacramentals
- Sacred Heart
- Sanctifying Grace
- Second Vatican Council
- Senator Helena Concannon
- Sex Education
- Spain
- St. Anne
- St. Dominic
- St. Francis de Sales
- St. Joseph
- St. Laurence O'Toole
- St. Oliver Plunkett
- St. Patrick
- St. Peter
- St. Rita of Cascia
- Sweden
- The Fall
- The Fold
- The Furrow
- The Irish Rosary
- The Standard
- Traditionalism
- Trinity
- TV
- Uncategorized
- Usury
- Vocationalism
- Vocations
- What is Christianity series?
- WW1
- WW2
Archive
Blogroll
- An Irish Catholic
- Andrea Tornielli
- Apocalypse Now
- Association of Catholic Priests
- Br André Marie
- Br Tom Forde
- Brendan Allen
- Brendan Doyle
- Brian Kelly
- Building 19th Century Ireland
- Caroline McCamley
- Catholic & Welsh
- Catholic Church Conservation
- Catholic of Thule
- Catholic Tide
- Catholic Truth
- Cedar Lounge Revolution
- Christophe Saint-Placide
- Christopher McCamley
- Clover Soldier
- David Quinn
- Desmond Fennell
- Devoción Católica
- Donum Vitae
- Eccles is saved
- Embajador en el Infierno
- Eoin O’Mahony
- Ephemeral Left
- Fionnchú
- Fr Anthony Cekada
- Fr Anthony Chadwick
- Fr Barnabus
- Fr Cathal Deveney
- Fr Eamonn Whelan
- Fr Gabriel Burke
- Fr Gerard Dunne OP
- Fr Hunwicke's Liturgical Notes
- Fr John Abberton
- Fr John Horgan
- Fr John Zuhlsdorf
- Fr Joseph S. O'Leary
- Fr Levi
- Fr Luuk Dominiek Jansen OP
- Fr Ray Blake
- Fr Sean Finnegan
- Fr Seán Coyle
- Fr Tim Finigan
- Fratres in Unum
- Garvan Hill
- Idle Speculations
- Irish Chesterton Society
- Irish Election Literature
- Jackie Parkes
- James Healy
- Joseph Shaw
- JSarto
- Kreuzfaehrten
- La Comedia Humana
- Le Forum Catholique
- Le Salon Beige
- Left Footer
- Lex Christianorum
- Liturgiae Causa
- Luke Scully
- Mark de Vries
- Mary O'Regan
- Messa in Latino
- Missa Gregoriana em Portugal
- Mundabor
- New Liturgical Movement
- New Theological Movement
- Opuscula
- Paolo Rodari
- Pat McNamara
- Peregrinus Hibernensis
- Petra
- Planet Catholic
- Porta Caeli
- Radio Cristiandad
- Remembering Fr William Doyle SJ
- Rev. Patrick Comerford
- Richard Collins
- Rinascimento Sacro
- Riposte Catholique
- Robert Fuller
- Rorate Caeli
- Saint Lawrence Press Blog
- Scottish Catholic Teuchtar
- Semper Fidelis
- Slugger O'Toole
- Society of St Oliver Plunkett
- Splintered Sunrise
- St Conleth's Catholic Heritage Association
- Słowianin w Irlandii
- Tea at Trianon
- The Chant Café
- The Eponymous Flower
- The Heresy Hunter
- The Irish Story
- The Muniment Room
- The Pulp.it
- The Thirsty Gargoyle
- Under the Oak
- Voices from Russia
- Young Canadian RC Male
Useful Resources
- Acta Apostolicae Sedis
- Analecta Hibernica (1930-2007) at JSTOR – Irish Manuscripts Commission
- Archivium Hibernicum (1912-2006) at JSTOR – Catholic Historical Society of Ireland
- Archivium Hibernicum – Catholic Historical Society of Ireland
- Athol Books (incl. Church and State)
- British Pathé
- Catholic Encyclopedia
- CELT – the online resource for Irish history
- Celt-archive Yahoo! group
- Celtic Digital Initiative
- Celtic Literature Collective
- Church Fathers
- Clogher Record (1953-2009) at JSTOR – Clogher Historical Society
- Comhar (1942-2007) at JSTOR
- Denzinger
- Documenta Catholica Omnia
- Documents in Irish Foreign Policy
- Douay-Rheims (original version)
- Early Irish Glossaries Database
- Golgotha Monastery Island Library
- Historical Dáil Debates
- Irish Historical Studies (1938-2005) at JSTOR
- Irish in Spain
- Irish Left Archive
- Irish Manuscripts On Screen
- Irish National Folklore Collection
- Irish Salem
- Irish Traditional Music Archive
- Ite ad Thomam Out-of-Print Library
- Jacques Maritain Center
- LibraryIreland
- Manuscript Sources to Old and Middle Irish Tales
- Monasticon Hibernicum
- Papal Encyclicals
- Pathways to Irish Research
- Persée
- Photopol
- Pontifical Irish College, Rome – Archives
- Seanchas Ardmhacha (1954-2006) at JSTOR – Armagh Diocesan Historical Society
- Society for Irish Latin American Studies
- Sources – National Library of Ireland
- St. Patrick's Confessio
- Studia Hibernica (1961-2009) at JSTOR
- Studies (1912-2007) at JSTOR – Irish Jesuits
- Studies – index of articles from 1912-1961
- Summa Theologica
- The Fold (1953-'60)
- The Furrow (1950-2007) at JSTOR
- The Irish Monthly (1873-1954) at JSTOR – Irish Jesuits
- Thesaurus Linguae Hibernicae
- Under the Oak
Weblinks
- Apostolate for the Faith
- Brandsma Review
- Cardinal Tomás Ó Fiaich Library & Archive
- Dublin Latin Mass Chaplaincy
- Eanna Johnson
- Irish Catholics' Forum
- Latin Mass Society of Ireland
- Mícheál Ó Cléirigh Institute for the Study of Irish History and Civilisation
- SSPX Ireland
- St Colman’s Society for Catholic Liturgy
- Teach The Faith
Angelqueen News
- An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.
Lux Occulta RSS Feed
Fascinating blogsite. Thanks Shane.
These book covers are certainly inviting to me.
Would reprints be possible, (possibly ebooks), do you think?
Thanks Brother Burrito. Welcome to the blog
You can have access to the whole pamphlet just by clicking on the cover. As for reprints, I think you’d probably need to ask the CTS. They sometimes do reprint old stuff but they tend to edit out the more ‘traditional’ bits. Someone on another blog commented on the shocking differences between the original 1957 Penny Catechism and the reprint.
Hello Shane,
this is shocking new to me.
I have a Penny catechism (not CTS) with imprimatur and indication of 1885 or the like as publishing year. I assume that what I have is identical to what one would have had in his hands then, right? If the text has been changed there should be an indication of the year of the modifications or am i wrong?
M
Mundabor, if it’s from 1885 and not CTS, I think it’s safe to assume that it’s the same.
BTW, did you read the Maynooth Catechism? How does it compare?
I haven’t checked the Maynooth thingy yet. But I am not worried as I can’t imagine that in 1885 Modernism had come so far as to infect catechisms. I’d rather say a publication of ten or fifteen years later, coming from France or anyway Western Europe, would have me a tad more diffident.
What I love in these old Catechisms is that they are so beautifully concise. Compare this with the Catechism of JP II, always saying in ten words what can be said in three, full of notes on V II and post V II documents and always trying to “sound good”. I know it is meant for a slightly different use, but the bad taste remains…
M
Agreed, I’m not a big fan of the new Catechism. It’s very verbose. I honestly don’t know why the Vatican just doesn’t just issue new editions of old catechisms (like St Pius X) – they’re vastly more concise. It’s a tragedy what’s been done to catechesis.
“I honestly don’t know why the Vatican just doesn’t just issue new editions of old catechisms.”
Because the old ones might actually be *read*. The JP II, with its verbousness and not being structured with the usual Q&A structure, is more likely to be ignored or, as some priests say, “directed more towards the priest”.
The Compendium issued by Benedict XVI is a vast improvement with his conciseness and the Q&A structure. Besides it is better formulated and rather exempt from the PC which afflicts the JP II’s one (as with almost everything JP II has published, one must say).
If you want to have some fun, google “Abbe de Nantes” and look at the twelve grave objections he had at the JP II’s Catechism and how the abbe himself said that the Compendium had eliminated all of them.
M
I have a copy of the Compendium. I agree that it’s a lot better than the Catechism – but of course it still lacks that preconciliar clarity.
I have read the Abbe’s book before. He’s an interesting figure. I think he once debated Yves Congar, I’ve been meaning to get a book on that.